Council spends £23,000 on a pile of logs

Carrs play area

Once upon a time – just a few weeks ago – on entering The Carrs from Wilmslow's Parish Hall, visitors had a beautiful view of rolling parkland and the River Bollin.

But all that greets them now is a hastily relocated "natural play area" made mainly from logs. Not any old logs, mind you, but logs from Norway rather than British forests. Which goes some way to explaining the eye-wateringly high cost of the playground: almost £23,000.*

Does that seem like good value?

As for its bizarre location, last year the Friends of The Carrs organisation reached agreement with the Council to locate the playground much further into the park, near to a picnic area from where mums and dads could keep an eye on their children – and nicely out of the way so that it did not spoil the view. So what went wrong?

Well, the logs and other materials were duly delivered and work began. Almost immediately, however, residents of nearby Bollin Hill complained and the Council promptly acquiesced to move it elsewhere without further discussion.

Hence its current location: guaranteed to be a blot on the landscape and away from both the picnic area and the existing main playground. There were several more sensible choices, including a large grassy area next to the main playground that would have been perfect, but in their apparent haste the Council seem not have even considered it. And that's why we've got the totally daft location of this overpriced white elephant.

Of course, given that The Carrs has acres of grass and rolling woodland, you may be wondering why it was necessary to spend £23,000 on a pile of logs. I was wondering that, too. But at least the dogs seem to like it.

*This figure was quoted to me in a response to a Freedom of Information request.

This is a member post by Graham Beech.

Tags:
Cheshire East Council, The Carrs
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Comments

Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below.

Ann Adamson
Tuesday 22nd February 2011 at 5:10 pm
I am flabbergasted - I cannot believe that this eye sore has cost £23,000. Have our councillors lost their minds??. The money would have been better spent cleaning the streets, which really are a mess with leaves still on the pavements since the Autumn. One minute we hear that the council is turning off street lights at night to make the town more enviromentally friendly and the next we hear that they have imported these logs all the way from Norway - surely this must be a joke.
Raymond Acton
Tuesday 22nd February 2011 at 5:53 pm
Is this before the bomb dropped on it or afterwards? And yet another wretched sign!!
Ray Acton
James MacDonald
Saturday 26th February 2011 at 9:19 am
We should cut the number of councillors and replace these type of decisions with local online referendums. Vote now! :-)
Mario West
Monday 28th February 2011 at 7:37 pm
I cannot see what is wrong with this scheme. It provides more play facilities for local children and uses natural sustainable materials. It is located near the car park and is therefore easy for the police to check on its use, rather than a trek across the park to an unlit area. it isn't on the doorstep of the neighbouring properties, thereby reducing the potential for nuisance from noise by its use, whereas the picnic area directly backs onto the gardens of Bollin Hill.
The area near the skate park is earmarked for other improvements.
It isn't obtrusive, I think the existing vista is still clearly visible.
With regards to the cost, perhaps Mr Beech should have provided a breakdown in costs, how much was the installation cost compared to the equipment purchase cost? Would it have made a significant difference in cost if the logs were sources from the UK? Are there any suppliers who use locally sourced wood? Were their prices comparable?
At a time when the council is cutting services/facilities it is actually refreshing to see that the council still values play and is improving the site, rather than letting it go to ruin.
Or perhaps there are other motives behind this story.
Philip Redfern
Wednesday 2nd March 2011 at 7:08 pm
I am a retired resident of Wilmslow who has enjoyed The Carrs for years to take my children and now grandchildren to for a visit. I have always thought how fortunate we are to have such lovely parks and plays areas around and about the area to visit for free which are often above the standard of many others parks further and wider. I think the new play area is a real gem, attractive, different and very fitting in its location, it's a delight to see something so different; it said to me that care and attention was paid to the choice for the park. Not being very mobile also means that for me and the grandchildren I don't have to far to walk to visit the play area, even better now that new benches have been fitted nearby to sit and enjoy watching our youngster enjoy themselves. We are very lucky to have a council investing in its parks and children while many do not, let's celebrate this new play area for the jolly good fun it is!
Douglas Ireland
Thursday 17th March 2011 at 2:36 pm
My children really enjoyed playing on this.
Stephanie Sankey
Thursday 17th March 2011 at 9:15 pm
I just wish the company I work for had been asked to quote for this scheme.

The owners of the company live in Wilmslow, most of its employees live in Wilmslow and most have children - I'm pretty sure we would have produced a very competitive quote!!!

Having said that, my children enjoyed the equipment with their friends last weekend.