Jane Shilton to close after decades of trading in Wilmslow

Jane Shilton is preparing to shut their shop on the corner of Water Lane and Grove Street, although no date has been confirmed for the closure as they need to find someone to take over the lease.

The family owned business, which is based in London, has been selling handbags and shoes at the prominent town centre location for decades.

A member of staff said the shop has been there for nearly 40 years.

She told wimslow.co.uk "We don't know when we're going to close. We were supposed to close in August but the people who were taking over the lease pulled out. We've got to sell the lease before we can go so we're just working a month's notice at a time.

"They are closing because of the lease, it is too expensive. Obviously we are trying to sell it on but still have about two and a half years on it."

2-4 Water Lane is being marketed as being available for rent at £51,950 a year with rates of £26,611.50 per annum.

Tags:
Jane Shilton
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Comments

Here's what readers have had to say so far. Why not add your thoughts below.

Ian Wilson
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 2:12 pm
Surprise surprise another shop in Wilmslow closing due to too high rent!!Cheshire East are doing a fantastic job in turning my home village into a ghost town!!! When are they going to see the light???
Anna Meadmore
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 3:43 pm
It will be sad to see yet another business close, especially one in such a prominent position. (I am not sure it has been there as long as nearly 40 years, as we moved here 27 years ago, and it was Cellini's for some time after that)
Simon Worthington
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 4:35 pm
So, almost 80K per annum before you put the key in the door. Add five or six staff and all the other overheads necessary for a retail business and the sum needed approaches 250K. Even selling goods with a large margin this site will be hard work for any honest business. It also illustrates where your hard earned cash goes when spent at retailers occupying high profile positions where the greedy landlords rub their hands with glee.
Angela Kapoor
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 5:06 pm
It's a smart shop in probably the most prominent location in town - it sets the tone for the whole place. Unless the incoming tenant operates a similarly upmarket business, the closure of Jane Shilton is bad news for anyone who cares about Wilmslow. Businesses struggle here because rents are artificially high (and then obviously rates on top). I'm certainly no expert but can only assume it's because there has always been a long list of national retailers desperate to sign up for space because on paper Wilmslow ticks all the boxes in terms of demographics - disposable income etc. The reality is that although there is plenty of money, our retailers suffer because local people do not spend in local shops. We need to support our town - homeowners need no more incentive than to consider the impact on the value of their property if their town centre goes down the tubes. Hopefully there will also come a point where rents become more realistic and all retailers (especially independents) stand a chance.
Dave Cash
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 5:44 pm
Ian, what does Cheshire East have to do with high rents, do they own the property?

The Valuation Office Agency (VOA) are responsible for assessing rateable value every few years, defined as the open market rent obtainable at time of assessment and this is multiplied by the rates multiplier set by central Govt each year (currently 47.1p/£ in Eng, exc London) or approx. 47% of current market rent. CEC only collect the business rates and keep approx. 50%

I remember the manager of Cellini's saying the proposed new rent was approx. £25K pa just before the shop closed.

High rents do affect any business' viability, included in any business plan, but the recent significant increase in internet shopping also had an effect on the High St, to which landlords and shop owners are only now reacting.
Ian Wilson
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 7:03 pm
Hi Dave, it was just based off a discussion I had with a person that works at the council a few months ago. Something needs to be done by whatever means to secure the future of wilmslow's shops. Sad to see.
Jason Lyons
Tuesday 21st January 2014 at 7:38 pm
Another one bites the dust!!! There's only going to Coffee & Phones shops left in Wilmslow!! Marketing & plenty of attractive incentives needed to get the good times back in leafy Wilmslow....
Dave Cash
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 1:37 am
Visions are currently in vogue for local planning forecasts .
Perhaps contributors can nominate businesses they would like to see in C Wilmslow at a commercial rent that reflects local private residential house values over the next 25 yrs?
Erik Garner
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 7:59 am
I'm trying to think of ways we could help the independent retailers of Wilmslow. We already have the Artisan Market, the Motor Show, Find the Gingerbread Man, Scare Crows, Incredible Edibles to bring attention to the town. What else could we do? The land lords obviously aren't going to lower rents and I don't know if free parking is going to produce the WOW factor needed to bring people in. I was in town on Saturday afternoon and Grove Street was very busy. However, of all the dozens of people walking around no one was carrying a shopping back from any of of our shops. Plenty of people but no one was buying. The coffee shops were all full but the shops were empty. How about a Wilmslow Loyalty Card for indie retailers? Late night shopping? A Wilmslow on Line Shopping website? I'm guilty of not really using the town centre for shopping but there's nothing for me there. I shop mainly online but I need to think "Try Wilmslow First!" Any other ideas?
Simon Worthington
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 10:01 am
The ludicrous rents will stay so long as we support those who pay it. Glasses wearers - the seven or eight opticians probably have running costs of well over a million, you pay. Coffee drinkers - the coffee costs around 8p, the cup and packaging 17p (source Sunday Times) where do you think the rest goes. House sellers - 2% (approx) for a photo and some blurb followed by a part timer to show prospective buyers round. Estate agents overheads in Wilmslow millions!!! Charity shops (blood starting to boil), don't supply jobs, take sales from genuine retailers, don't pay full rates but DO pay full rents and attract scavengers who don't spend in other shops. This was very obvious when the Artisan market was on Saturdays.
I also wonder how much rent our favourite "developer" takes from the three retail units and offices in our prime sited job centre? That leaves phone shops and then banks/building societies - draw your own conclusions on the rents they pay out of your money.
John Bowden
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 11:26 am
'Scavengers who don't spend in other shops' - Simon Worthington on people who use Charity Shops. Obviously you can only shop in Charity shops OR 'genuine' retailers. What a great sweeping generalisation!
Steph Walsh
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 1:01 pm
I don't approve of charity shops for several reasons, many of which have been listed by Simon, but the most important one is that they have been proven to 'lower the tone' of a high street. The Financial Times wrote about this at the end of 2012 or so, and listed other such signifiers of low commercial vitality and viability which are also proven to drag down residential desirability. Wilmslow has changed a lot over the space of a few scant years and the crawl out of the black hole of charity shops/mobile phone shops/banks will be an extremely arduous task.

John, don't take Simon's comment personally, I doubt it was meant that way. Of course one can shop in charity shops and all other shops too but Simon is right in saying that a raft of charity shops attracts the type of clientele who wants only more of it, it's called their target market. And their target market isn't gonna be the same as Worthington's target market, except it will impinge on the look and feel that will keep Worthington's target market away from the current Wilmslow scene (see what The FT has to say about it, this isn't my personal agenda, it's the principle of like attracts like).

However, shops should have a business plan that includes their rates and costs, while my impression, corroborated by the extremely short-lived experiences of Lola especially and Caroline of Water Lane, to name but only two, indicate that too many people operate under the assumption that 'if you open, they'll come'. They don't. And when they don't come, that's usually because you don't give them what they want when they want it. The prospect of an empty unit isn't thrilling but I won't miss Jane Shilton, for I never found anything remotely to my taste in there. Rent (and other rates) notwithstanding, if they actually sold stock like hotcakes (say... like Nero and Starbs and SpaceNK do), they wouldn't be closing down.
Donald Patterson
Wednesday 22nd January 2014 at 11:32 pm
The problem is nationwide not just in Wilmslow, why would you go into Wilmslow to shop with such a small selection of shops when you can go to John Lewis or the Trafford Centre and get everything under one roof?? there are no empty shops in the Trafford Centre and I bet the rent and rates are sky high there!! the only way to revive the high street is for landlords to lower rents and valuation offices to lower rates, this will attract more retailers and then more shoppers, the answer isn't to put an Artisan Market on once a month, this just attracts people from out of town that don't spend any money (except in the charity shops), and for me personally, I stay away from the town centre when they are on because its the same old things every time. The council, landlords and business rates guys all need to get together and come up with incentives to attract and help businesses survive and compete with the internet and out of town shopping, then once the shops are full, we can come up with a scheme for local people to support them.
Tate Jones
Thursday 23rd January 2014 at 11:25 am
Greetings from Bank Square!

So, I had an interesting conversation with a group at a networking event in Wilmslow regarding our residents fear of entering a independent shop. They said they were basically scared of entering a local shop, due to the fear of pressure, the guilt of not buying- and the prices. They also assume the choice isn't there and assuming the same product can be bought in Stockport, Trafford Centre and online- and a lot cheaper- without even entering! This wasn't just about our shop but about indies in general in Wilmslow. It's also hard when locals write off indies without giving us a chance and by saying, "oh, I'll give them 6 months..." It takes a lot of planning, graft and guts to set up and run a business and it's easy to overlook this. Most are family run, residing in Wilmslow. The money isn't channelled to HQ- it is used and spent locally.

There seems to be a lot of people concerned but are they actually supporting local businesses? I'm not alone when it comes to this but some of the complainers about the situation in Wilmslow seem to be the ones not supporting by going to Manchester, Stockport or online. There have been some great events to help such as Artisan Market, which we love and wish were on Saturdays ( btw, we were the the handful of shops that opened last Sunday to support the market when we wanted the market to stay on a Sat), The Wilmslow Motor Show is fab! And the Gingerbread Hunt was so much fun and was a great way to get people out. So, we can do all these things and do more with marketing, loyalty schemes etc but surely more can be done by the people who reside in Wilmslow.

On the other hand, many locals value the indies here. For example, we've built a lovely client base with people from Wilmslow, Alderley Edge, Prestbury and Hale as well as Lindow School, Gorsey Bank School, Rileys, Wilmslow High School, and Premier Football Coaching (PFC) in just 6 months of trading and we hope more people, schools and local businesses will follow as we grow so we can improve the variety of brands and service we can offer. These are fine examples of how to support local businesses- they've taken a chance. Indies only need a few more to follow their example and it could be a jumping, and bouncing high street. There's a very fine line in retail in a town...it's not like indies here need hundreds and thousands of people to shop.

Finally, what's happening this month is quite normal in business. It's notoriously slow following xmas. Some businesses decide to pull the plug after a disappointing xmas and avoid more loss. But I'm sure it will settle down in Feb. Retail, and especially in this town, is about waves and indies must be ready to adapt when these come by- and prepared when they don't. We need more unique, friendly shops with a good variety providing exceptional service and competitive prices, always! The people of Wilmslow and beyond do appreciate friendly and top service.

We firmly believe that Wilmslow can be great again! We're remaining positive and a big thank you to those working on projects/events to increase footfall and obviously our awesome customers! We enjoy being here.

Tate (The Goal Post).
Simon Worthington
Thursday 23rd January 2014 at 12:59 pm
I stated that Charity shops attract those who do not spend in other shops. I did not say that all their customers fell into this category but some undoubtedly do as I witnessed many times when the Artisan market was on Saturdays. Unfortunately the word "market" implies to some people that goods will be cheaper than in retail outlets - quite the opposite with our Artisan market!! Therefore those visitors busied themselves rooting along the charity shop rails!!
My point was intended to be that the high costs of running retail premises will be reflected in the prices. If you can sell online from cheaply run warehouses and then evade tax by international skulduggery then, as we have witnessed countrywide over the last few years, the shops will close!!